Campaign Crafter | Exploring Different Types of D&D Games: Find the Perfect Fit for Your Table
Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) offers a rich tapestry of ways to play, making it one of the most versatile tabletop games in existence. Whether you're a new player curious about your options or a seasoned Dungeon Master (DM) looking to spice things up, understanding the different game types can help you tailor your sessions to your group’s needs. Here’s a breakdown of popular game formats and their strengths and weaknesses to help you craft the perfect experience. Here’s a step-by-step guide for new DMs to elevate their game and make every session memorable!
No time to read? Listen to the Campaign Crafter Podcast: Understanding Ways to Play RPGs on your drive or while working instead.
Understanding Ways to Play RPGs
Every D&D group is unique, and the "right" game type depends on your players' schedules, interests, and creative goals. Want an epic, Tolkien-esque adventure? Go for a campaign. Need flexibility? Episodic games or one-shots might be your answer. Experiment with these formats and discover what keeps your table rolling the dice!
Ready to craft your next adventure? Remember, the key to a great game isn’t the format—it’s the shared stories and memories you create together.
1. Single DM Games: A Classic Approach
The single DM model is the traditional structure most people associate with D&D. One person serves as the DM, orchestrating a series of adventures that often form a cohesive story arc.
Why Choose a Single DM Game?
Clear Roles: Everyone knows their role, and the DM has full control over the narrative and game mechanics.
Continuity: A single vision ensures a consistent tone and story progression.
Potential Drawbacks
High DM Workload: From planning intricate plots to managing encounters, the DM does most of the heavy lifting.
Dependency on the DM: If the DM is unavailable, the game grinds to a halt.
2. Multiple DM Games: Collaboration at Its Best
In this format, multiple players take turns as the DM, sharing the responsibilities of running the game. This setup works well for groups that want to avoid burnout or explore diverse storytelling styles.
Why Choose Multiple DM Games?
Shared Workload: Preparing adventures is less daunting when everyone pitches in.
Inclusivity: All players feel more connected to the group, fostering collaboration and creativity.
Continuity Backup: If one DM can’t make it, another can step in.
Potential Drawbacks
Continuity Challenges: Story consistency can waver as different DMs bring their unique approaches.
Character Absences: A DM’s character often sits out during their session, which can feel disjointed.
DMing can be Hard. Prepare less and play more with the Legendary Sly Flourish’s award winning Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master.
3. Campaign Games: Epic Storytelling
A campaign is a series of interconnected adventures forming a grand narrative. This is the format for groups wanting to embark on a shared journey full of evolving characters and plots.
Why Choose a Campaign Game?
Immersive Storytelling: Build a sprawling, epic fantasy narrative that feels like a novel or TV series.
Lasting Consequences: Choices and events in one session impact the entire story.
Potential Drawbacks
Burnout Risk: A long-running campaign can be exhausting for the DM and players.
Stalled Stories: If the DM steps away, the story might never see its conclusion.
Looking for the perfect holiday gift for your Dungeons and Dragons family or friend? The Ultimate Gift Guide for Dungeons & Dragons Enthusiasts
4. Episodic Games: Adventure-of-the-Week
In episodic games, each session is a self-contained story. While there may be recurring characters or themes, the adventures don’t necessarily connect to a larger plot.
Why Choose an Episodic Game?
Flexibility: Perfect for groups that can’t commit to a continuous campaign.
Ease of Preparation: Published adventures or quick homebrew scenarios fit seamlessly into this format.
Potential Drawbacks
Lack of Purpose: Disconnected stories can feel aimless over time.
Character Development: Players might miss the deeper growth that comes with a campaign.
ELIMINATE BATTLEFIELD CONFUSION: Easily & clearly track the most frequently used spell & ability effects. The perfect gift (for yourself or a friend)DND Miniatures Condition Markers
5. Ongoing Games: A Recurring Tradition
An ongoing game refers to a regular gathering of the same players, regardless of the format. It might be campaign-based, episodic, or a mix of both.
Why Choose an Ongoing Game?
Group Chemistry: Familiar players develop camaraderie and cooperation.
Consistent Playstyle: Groups can refine their dynamics over time.
Potential Drawbacks
Limited Exposure: Regular play with the same people may stifle creative growth.
Group Dynamics Dependence: The success of the game heavily relies on established relationships.
For more tips on how to be a better dungeon master. We recommend checking out the ENnies award winner book, THE RETURN OF THE LAZY DUNGEON MASTER by the legendary Sly Flourish.
6. One-Shot Games and Convention Events: Short and Sweet
One-shots are single-session adventures, often played at conventions or gaming events. They can also be a fun break for established groups looking for variety.
Why Choose a One-Shot Game?
Experimentation: Try new characters, rules, or settings without long-term commitments.
Networking: Meet new players and get fresh ideas for your regular games.
Low Commitment: Perfect for players with limited availability.
Potential Drawbacks
Group Chemistry: Playing with strangers can be hit or miss.
Incompatibility: The style or tone may not align with your preferences.
For more tips on How to Be a Dungeon Master, hear what an expert has to say.
Craft the Perfect Game for Your Table
Choosing the right type of D&D game can transform your sessions into memorable adventures. Whether you opt for the consistency of a single DM campaign, the creativity of multiple DMs, the flexibility of episodic games, or the spontaneity of one-shots, the key is to match the format to your group’s interests and schedules. Experiment, collaborate, and most importantly, have fun creating stories together. No matter the style, the magic of D&D lies in the shared journey. Now, it’s time to roll initiative and bring your game to life!
With these tips, you’ll be well on your way to becoming an excellent Dungeon Master. Good luck, and may your rolls be ever in your favor!
For more tips, check out our other blog posts.
